Friday, April 4, 2014

Metzorah 5774


Metzorah, this week’s parshah, describes the skin condition of tzora’at.  Previously, tzora’at was mistakenly identified as leprosy (Hansen’s Disease).  The parshah describes the ritual for spiritual purification of the sufferer.

Rabbis are regularly asked, “Why me?” when someone gets sick.  It’s a powerful question, full of anguish.  I have asked it myself, in times of loss and confusion.  The question expresses a belief, found in the Torah, that illness can be a moral statement rather than a medical one.  It can sometimes feel as if suffering were a moral judgment, a punishment doled out by a disapproving God like a bitter headmaster with his wooden ruler.  Painful as that idea is, some find it more soothing than grappling with the idea that the universe is incomprehensible to us, that neither success nor failure are moral indications.  Pain doesn’t make sense.

Jewish tradition does not believe that suffering is redemptive.  It does not come to punish us, nor to teach us a lesson.  I do not believe that we are given pain in order to help us grow. 

That said, we may indeed learn and grow from our suffering.  This is a subtle, but very important difference.  I have certainly learned from my pain, but I do not believe that the pain was “sent to me” in order that I might learn those lessons.  The pain is just pain, no more nor less.  The meaning I make of it is up to me.

No comments: